Summer 2019 - By Dr. Jim Mead, Mammoth Site Director of Research
How was this summer’s Ice Age Explorers dig?
“We had a great group of folks throughout June for our Ice Age Explorers season. Two newcomers and the rest as return folks. All was fantastic. Some folks excavated the entire time, some sorted bone from Persistence Cave, some worked on preparation, and some mixed-n-matched as they wanted. It was wonderful. So much was accomplished. In the east end of the sinkhole, I had the excavators basically chop out chunks of clay and then split them along the bedding plane which was usually a thin layer of silt or sand. In so doing we are now fairly consistently recovering plant remains – bits and pieces of wood and grass being replaced by iron and or manganese. Marianne did recover what appears to be a very nice insect leg. A single fish remain upon detail examination is actually two fish skeletons. So our approach is paying off nicely. Fairly large areas were taken down. Previously discovered remains (such as an articulated foot) were fully exposed. We are nicely getting toward following the ‘bone plane’ that includes Murray heading deeper and toward the center of the sinkhole. Although there is obviously much more to do, the course is set for a couple of years to come. A couple of folks worked diligently on defining the sinkhole edge and contact with sediments and bones – this is a critical location towards the southeast end that we need to better understand to define the wall of the sinkhole. Biz ‘and gang’ removed the large mandible at the southwest end where Vee’s skull was removed years ago – this area is now unofficially labeled “Bizneyland.”
What is the latest on the Snake River Fossil Site?
“In earliest May, Sandy Swift, Sharon Holte, Presston Gabel, Biz Storms, Bethany Cook, and a number of colleagues from Texas, Arizona, and Wisconsin, and joined by two experienced Ice Age Explorers (Lynn and Susan), helped me analyze the bison coming out of a bog deposit in Tom and Gail’s Snake River Farm (south of St. Cloud, eastern Minnesota). We did this early in May to avoid the mosquitos of later May and June but that meant we might have rain and snow…which we experienced in all its glory!! Fun in the mud is the bottom line. We have now pretty much cleaned all the recovered bison bones and begun analyzing all for details. I hope to have a radiocarbon date on a beaver-chewed stick by the end of summer. This should provide an age for the beautiful adult female Bison antiquus skeleton Arturo Baez was recovering.”
What have you been up to this summer?
“It has been a very busy summer for me (see above). Sandy and I attended the Biology of Pitvipers conference in Rodeo, New Mexico, where we presented our work on the morphology of the skull of Asian and North American vipers. Then we went on to work with colleagues Dr. Steve Emslie (MS Science Associate, U NC Wilmington) and Larry Coats (University of Utah) on two caves in the Northern Snake Range of the Great Basin at the Nevada/Utah border. I worked this area back in the late 1970s and early 80s. In August I headed to Hills, Minnesota to understand the mammoth and bison remains being unearthed in a farmer’s backyard.”
What can we look forward to in new publications?
“Publications are coming together regarding proboscideans from all National Parks in the USA and an overview of the Ice Age fossils, environments, and cave localities in Grand Canyon National Park, Arizona. Plans are being made for late September to work with NPS folks about another cave excavation along with helping the 100-year-old Grand Canyon National Park celebrate National Fossil Day. From there Sandy and I head to two caves in the Trans-Pecos region of west Texas, to help archaeologists understand the mats of Shasta Ground Sloth dung being discovered below cultural layers. And of course Sandy, Sharon Holte, and I with the help of Dr. Chris Jass (Royal Alberta Museum) will continue our work in September on excavations and faunal remains from Persistence Cave and Parker’s Pit here in the Black Hills.”
How did the Intern program go this summer?
“Once again we had 10 interns for our summer season. A great and diverse set of college and graduate students from around the country were divided into education and paleo-conservation groups. All were of a great help. And all were still housed in our current (and inadequate) dorm housing. We hope that The Mammoth Site Field Station that Presston and I have been planning for some time now will actually be on-site come September. This field station will permit us to have definitely better housing for our interns but also for a number of visiting researchers and summer field school projects from visiting colleges around the country wanting to study in the Black Hills region.”
Snake River Fossil Site May 2019 Expedition
1. What do bison have to do with The Mammoth Site?
The Mammoth Site albeit focuses on mammoths, yet the research conducted here really is about ‘everything Ice Age’. Our research will concentrate on predominantly the Black Hills and that undefined fringed around it (WY, SD plains, NE), we do have other Ice Age projects in caves within the Grand Canyon and in the central Great Basin (Nevada). So – our study of the Bison and then how we teach about their evolution and exhibit them in our museum area is right in line with our mission. Interestingly, there are no bison fossils in The Mammoth Site sinkhole deposit. The reason seems to be that the sinkhole sediments which are dating about 140,000 back to greater than 190,000 years old are before bison were here, or at least common, in North America south of the Canadian ice caps during the glacial period. As ice began to melt, causeways opened up from Beringia (that region from the Yukon, Alaska, to Siberia) allowing bison to disperse south into what we know as the USA and into Mexico.
2. All in all, how did it go?
Our excavation from May 4-10 was terrific. We were able to locate what appears to be a large bone bed of bison skeletons which the Snake River let us see it by carving a path through the center. We are not sure just how great an expanse it covers but we know it has some very large bison in it (some researchers would say that these are Bison antiquus, the extinct Ice Age bison) and some are smaller, about the size of our existing bison (Bison bison). The bison of today are actually the smallest bison that have ever existed. The bison bone bed is about 12 in. (20 cm.) below current river level so excavators are always deep in black bog mud! We know that we will go back to the Snake River Farm in 2020 to open up a larger area of the bone bed to better understand it. Questions that I have include: how many bison are there?; how many years ago did this bone bed happen?; why was the bone bed created – what caused it?; what time of year/season did it happen?
3. What did you find and what would you say is the most remarkable find?
We found LOTS of bison bones. Some were disarticulated and some were articulated (in life position and connected). We have many individual ages of bison – i.e., it was a herd of some sort and some size. The most remarkable find I think is that we have so many LARGE bison. One skull is of a probably 12-14 year old….big and heavy. At first I thought it was a bull but the horn cores indicate it is a female. I feel pretty confident we have at least some Bison antiquus. We also found some turtle and MANY lengths of wood with many chewed on by a beaver!
4. What happens next to all these bones?
So the skeletal remains that we removed will now be cleaned up – to get all the bog mud removed. They will be dried out and repaired if they need it. Then we begin the long process of determining what skeletal elements we recovered, do some measurements, and then surely get a radiocarbon date both on the beaver-chewed wood and the bison bone.
5. When is the next dig and what do you hope to find?
Our next excavation is tentatively planned for early May 2020. We want to avoid the mosquitoes but the price to pay for this is be ready for lots of rain and some snow (as we had this year!). I want to find out how big a bone bed we have and answer the questions that I presented above. In any case, it will be extremely interesting and fun!!
Bison Skull & Vertebrae
Fall 2019 – by Dr. Jim Mead, Mammoth Site, Director of Research
1. What new ancient dung projects have you been doing?
In early October, I went down to the Sierra Vieja Mountains, south of Marfa, Trans-Pecos Texas, to meet up with Dr. Bryon Schroeder. He is an archaeologist for the Center for Big Bend Studies, Sul Ross State University in Alpine, Texas. Bryon is excavating Spirit Eye Cave for its great preservation of corn, baskets, and other perishable Archaic artifacts. In some dry corners of the cave and under some layers of cultural remains, he recovered some strange organic material. When we discussed his discovery via email, we determined that we both needed to go out to this remote cave. What he has encountered is dung from the extinct Shasta ground sloth, Nothrotheriops shastensis. Preliminary radiocarbon analyses indicate the dung is at least 12,000 years old and some much, much older. He and I are now working on the plants recovered from the dung and adjacent packrat middens (rodent nest filled with macrobotanical fossils)! This project is very exciting, fun, and definitely providing a new aroma for our MicroFaunal Lab during analyses!
The picture shows a snapshot of some of the fragmented sloth dung recovered from the cave. These remains were likely from a juvenile sloth.
2. What is happening in the MicroFaunal Lab?
Sandy Swift has been more than busy volunteering her hours washing sediments and sorting bones from those sediments from Parker’s Pit cave and Persistence Cave – both projects here in the southern Black Hills. Chris Jass (Royal Alberta Museum), Sharon Holte (Mammoth Site staff), along with an excellent crew of volunteer excavators from Denver, worked at getting the sediments out of Parker’s Pit. Sandy and some of the Denver crew washed and sorted some of the material in September. Now that it is basically winter here, Sandy has been putting in long hours finishing off the ‘tonnage’ of bone sorting. Great fossils are being discovered.
Sandy is helping me a lot working on the packrat middens from Spirit Eye Cave, TX. I am getting various analytical analyses conducted on the sloth dung from this cave at various labs at the University of Arizona and Northern Arizona University. I want to know what the sloths were eating – this too will tell me what the plant community was like around the cave where today it is a typical arid Chihuahuan Desert.
3. How did you interact with the 2019 National Fossil Day?
Well, this year the National Park Service decided to hold the National Fossil Day at Grand Canyon National Park in northern Arizona. Because this park is officially 100 years old this year, the NPS decided to hold various festivities in the park. Three colleagues from around the nation, and I presented public lectures one Friday evening. My discussion was about the Ice Age in the Grand Canyon. It was a blast…tonnage of questions much of the night. On the following Saturday, there were booths set up in the courtyard at the Visitors Center. Hundreds and hundreds of visitors. I helped with the caves and fossils booth set up by National Cave and Karst Research Institute (Carlsbad, NMx). Tule Springs fossil site was there, along with the Museum of Northern Arizona, and a bunch more! What a full weekend it was. It was good to have The Mammoth Site in the center of this big event! Next year should be fun too, but I am not going to let the cat out of the bag!!!!
4. What might we see for new exhibits this coming year?
Well, right now we have a GREAT new exhibit about bison and the Plains. The exhibit was produced by the National Buffalo Foundation and collaborators. We will have this exhibit here until about early February.
After this Bison exhibit, we will move toward some temporary exhibit topics about 1) modern and fossil Dung – what does it tell us, and 2) the California Channel Islands mammoths. Lots to show and tell here at The Mammoth Site. And speaking of bison…we are continuing to work on the bison fossils recovered from the Snake River Fossil Site, MN. So much to do with this locality and, we will go back there May 2020. Much to do, much to do...must get busy!!!
5. What new publications did you do this year?
Here are some articles published this year, 2019. If you want a copy of any of these, just let me know which and I will send you a pdf.
· Paleontology of caves. Chapter 96. Encyclopedia of Caves. Authors: BW Schubert and JIM.
· Ancient DNA Rewrites the Evolutionary History and Biogeography of Sloths. Authors: F. Delsuc, M. Kuch, G. C. Gibb, E. Karpinski, D.Hackenberger, P. Szpak, J.G. Martínez, JIM, H.G. McDonald, R.D.E. MacPhee, G. Billet, L. Hautier, and H. N. Poinar. Current Biology.
· Late Pleistocene Mammuthus and Cuvieronius (Proboscidea) from Térapa, Sonora, Mexico. Authors: JIM, Joaquin Arroyo-Cabrales [Mexico] and Sandra L. Swift. Quaternary Science Review, on-line now.
Here are the manuscripts for articles that are either in press (due out soon) or are in some form of review. I have more that are in preparation.
1. Proboscideans from the U.S. National Park Service Lands. JIM plus 4 others. Accepted for press but need to make a few changes. Article requested by NPS. Eastern Paleontologist.
2. Late Pleistocene salamander (Ambystomatidae; Caudata; Amphibia) from Térapa, Sonora, Mexico. JIM. First fossil salamander from Sonora, Mexico. To be published in July 2019. NMx Nat Hist Mus of Sci Bulletin.
3. A review of salamanders (Amphibia: Caudata) from Plio-Pleistocene of Arizona and New Mexico, USA. Darcy, JIM, Morgan. To be published in July, 2019. NMx Nat Hist Mus of Sci Bulletin.
4. Ice Age (Pleistocene) flora, fauna, environments, and climate of the Grand Canyon, Arizona. JIM plus 5 others. Manuscript requested by NPS. In review.